MotionMiniReview < Keck/NGAO

---++ NGAO Motion Control Architecture Mini Design Review, 11 March 2010

*Review Schedule*
   * Material to web site: 4-Mar
   * Response from reviewers due: end of day 9-Mar
   * Design group's response to reviewer questions: as soon as possible
   * Review meeting: 8:00am-12:00pm (HST) 11-Mar

   * Videoconference IP: 128.171.99.70 (Hualalai)
   * Telecon number: 1-877-280-4645 Guest Room: 540030

Links to review materials
   * Charge to Reviewers
      * [[%ATTACHURL%/MC_miniReview_charter_v1.pdf][MC_miniReview_charter_v1.pdf]]: Review Committee charter document

   * Requirements
      * See section 7 of KAON 715 (below)
   * Design Documents
      * %RED% *The version of the documents listed below is frozen as of 4-Mar-10, 17:00 HST.<br>
          These are the versions pertinent to the mini-review on 11-Mar-10. After the review, see NewKAONs
 For the most current version* %ENDCOLOR%
      * [[http://www.oir.caltech.edu/twiki_oir/bin/viewfile/Keck/NGAO/NewKAONs?rev=1;filename=KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign.doc][KAON 715: Preliminary Motion Control Design]] (v1.0)
         * This will be the PD document for the NGAO Motion Controls. <br>
            Each subsystem is broken down and discussed in as much detail as possible.<br>
            As this effort relies heavily on the subsystem designs, this document remains a work in progress. 
      * [[http://www.oir.caltech.edu/twiki_oir/bin/viewfile/Keck/NGAO/NewKAONs?rev=3;filename=KAON682_NGAO_Master_Device_List.xls][KAON 682: Master Device List Excel Spreadsheet]] (v1.2)
         * This document captures all of the known devices controlled by the AO or LGS control system. <br>
             RTC devices are not listed. <br>
            There are two tabs, one for motion devices and one for non-motion devices (not part of this review).<br>
      * [[http://www.oir.caltech.edu/twiki_oir/bin/viewfile/Keck/NGAO/NewKAONs?rev=2;filename=KAON643_NGAO_MotionControlArchitectureStudy.doc][KAON 668: Motioin Control Architecture Study]] (v1.5)
         * This document presents an initial study into the motion control requirements and possible architectures.<br>
         * This document has not been revised to reflect the current quantity and type of devices expected in the NGAO system.

   * Supplemental Materials
      * [[%NGAO_KAON%KAON511_NGAO_SDM_v2.1.doc][KAON 511: System Design Manual v2.1 (doc)]] 
      * [[%NGAO_KAON%KAON642_NGAO_Design_Changes.doc][KAON 642: Design Changes in Support of Build-to-Cost]]

   * Reviewer Comments
      * [[%ATTACHURL%/KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.pdf][KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.pdf]]: KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign with Alex's comments
         * [[%ATTACHURL%/Limit_switch_with_distance_and_direction.pdf][Limit_switch_with_distance_and_direction.pdf]]: Limit Switch with direction and distance
      * [[%ATTACHURL%/Questions_Comments_JC.doc][Questions_Comments_JC.doc]]: Feedback from Jason
      * [[%ATTACHURL%/CommentsOnMotionControlReview_DG.doc][CommentsOnMotionControlReview_DG.doc]]: comments from Don
   * Response To Reviewer Comments

   * *Review Presentation [[%ATTACHURL%/mc_MiniReview_presentation_v1.ppt][.ppt]]*


   * Reviewers' final report

Reviewer panel:
   * Don Gavel (chair)
   * Alex Delacroix
   * Tomas Krasuski

-- Main.EdWetherell - 18 Feb 2010

Attachments

Topic attachments
I	Attachment	History	Action	Size	Date	Who	Comment
doc	CommentsOnMotionControlReview_DG.doc	r1	manage	56.5 K	2010-03-11 - 06:26	UnknownUser	comments from Don
doc	KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.doc	r1	manage	5245.5 K	2010-03-09 - 00:43	UnknownUser	KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign with Alex's comments
pdf	KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.pdf	r1	manage	603.6 K	2010-03-09 - 00:48	UnknownUser	* KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.doc: KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign with Alex's comments
pdf	Limit_switch_with_distance_and_direction.pdf	r1	manage	259.7 K	2010-03-08 - 21:20	UnknownUser	Limit Switch with direction and distance
pdf	MC_miniReview_charter_v1.pdf	r2 r1	manage	37.9 K	2010-03-02 - 02:18	UnknownUser	Motion Control Mini-Review Charter
ppt	MC_miniReview_presentation_v1.ppt	r1	manage	5098.0 K	2010-03-11 - 06:25	UnknownUser	mini-review presentation
doc	Questions_Comments_JC.doc	r1	manage	53.0 K	2010-03-10 - 00:34	UnknownUser	Feedback from Jason

This topic: Keck/NGAO > WebHome > ControlsSystems > ControlsSystemsHWArch > MotionMiniReview
Topic revision: r13 - 2010-03-11 - EdWetherell