Difference: NEOZTFScanning_HowToFMO (1 vs. 2)

Revision 22018-08-10 - EmilyKramer

Line: 1 to 1
 
META TOPICPARENT name="NEOZTFScanning"
Changed:
<
<
How to find Fast Moving Objects (FMOs)
>
>

How to find Fast Moving Objects (FMOs)

  Originally by Quan-Zhi Ye

You will be given a number of "stamps" that contain plausible FMOs identified by the ZTF pipeline. The challenge is to identify what we would consider a real (asteroidal) FMO.

Changed:
<
<
What does a real FMO look like?
>
>

What does a real FMO look like?

  A real FMO will look like a star smeared across the image. The edge should be soft due to atmospheric and optic effect on the light, and the width and brightness should be somewhat uniform. As ZTF has relatively short exposure time (30 seconds), a real asteroidal FMO usually does not extend beyond the size of the stamp (which is about 150 by 150 arcsec). Anything longer than that is most likely an artificial object.
Line: 22 to 22
 41264667-d3a6b378-6da2-11e8-9b8a-d4816b809285.jpg Not all FMOs are as bright as the examples shown above. Actually, most new ones are faint -- like this one (R~18.5).
Changed:
<
<
Common falses
>
>

Common falses

 
Changed:
<
<
### Long tracks caused by artificial objects (satellites, aircrafts, space debris)
>
>

Long tracks caused by artificial objects (satellites, aircrafts, space debris)

  The most common falses are artificial objects. Anything that extends beyond the edge of the stamp or shows non-uniform changes in width or brightness is most likely artificial objects -- don't bother!
Line: 39 to 39
 40272287-bbb4f432-5b5f-11e8-94ce-cbe93b52d070.jpg This is too long to be a real FMO, note that some portions are masked out by the ZTF pipeline
Changed:
<
<
## Flashes caused by artificial objects
>
>

Flashes caused by artificial objects

  Similar to the category above but objects in this class can be quite confusing -- remember that anything that shows non-uniform changes in width or brightness is most likely artificial objects.
Changed:
<
<
![strkid5033298019150001_pid503329801915_scimref](40272285-bb53b640-5b5f-11e8-94ff-668e2531e87f.jpg)
>
>
40272285-bb53b640-5b5f-11e8-94ff-668e2531e87f.jpg
 This candidate is short in length, however the brightness is not uniform along the streak, therefore it is most likely a satellite flash
Changed:
<
<
![strkid5033038548150003_pid503303854815_scimref](40272286-bb738344-5b5f-11e8-9db3-8792eca4f466.jpg)
>
>
40272286-bb738344-5b5f-11e8-9db3-8792eca4f466.jpg
 This object is apparently flashing
Changed:
<
<
![strkid5082263559150009_pid508226355915_scimref](40502300-655fc2c2-5f3f-11e8-83b5-fdedb1a2100b.jpg)
>
>
40502300-655fc2c2-5f3f-11e8-83b5-fdedb1a2100b.jpg
 Another object that flashes periodically
Changed:
<
<
![strkid5083605902150005_pid508360590215_scimref](40502301-65819438-5f3f-11e8-884e-13de8e6a9c08.jpg)
>
>
40502301-65819438-5f3f-11e8-884e-13de8e6a9c08.jpg
 Flash, note that both ends are fading away
Changed:
<
<
![strkid5083687555150007_pid508368755515_scimref](40502302-659eddc2-5f3f-11e8-9c1f-b2573bf29a74.jpg)
>
>
40502302-659eddc2-5f3f-11e8-9c1f-b2573bf29a74.jpg
 Flash, note that both ends are fading away
Changed:
<
<
### Masked bright star and/or its diffraction spikes
>
>

Masked bright star and/or its diffraction spikes

  These are found next to a bright, and usually masked, star.
Changed:
<
<
![strkid5034440300150003_pid503444030015_scimref](40272423-96eb108a-5b61-11e8-929d-1ad302fdb1d3.jpg) ![strkid5034107027150003_pid503410702715_scimref](40272424-971a67b8-5b61-11e8-9f8e-8fde959eefb7.jpg) ![strkid5034793134150004_pid503479313415_scimref](40272425-973aceea-5b61-11e8-9728-58a2f06bfcf3.jpg)
>
>
40272423-96eb108a-5b61-11e8-929d-1ad302fdb1d3.jpg 40272424-971a67b8-5b61-11e8-9f8e-8fde959eefb7.jpg 40272425-973aceea-5b61-11e8-9728-58a2f06bfcf3.jpg
 
Changed:
<
<
### Dementors and ghosts
>
>

Dementors and ghosts

  Various optical illusions can generate FMO-like features. Compared to real FMOs, optical illusions are more fuzzy, with variable brightness along the track, and are usually non-linear.
Changed:
<
<
![strkid5033932721150001_pid503393272115_scimref](40272398-4ec4c580-5b61-11e8-85c2-825a5c332636.jpg) ![strkid5033676561150005_pid503367656115_scimref](40272399-4ee70f28-5b61-11e8-9f0c-76a07ff0c7dd.jpg) ![strkid5033676552150005_pid503367655215_scimref](40272400-4f0526b6-5b61-11e8-9dee-5843430c226c.jpg) ![strkid5033810361150002_pid503381036115_scimref](40272401-4f3e03b4-5b61-11e8-827d-e62e9e06c9c0.jpg) ![strkid5033932719150005_pid503393271915_scimref](40272402-4f69b054-5b61-11e8-80c7-a13f9c6ef874.jpg) ![strkid5032262201150001_pid503226220115_scimref](40272403-4fc953e2-5b61-11e8-8295-9c9aa1b76a94.jpg) ![strkid5082246151150001_pid508224615115_scimref](40503445-ed5d77f2-5f42-11e8-97f5-6148da998ecf.jpg) ![strkid5082201203150001_pid508220120315_scimref](40503446-ed78eff0-5f42-11e8-807d-be79ac09b5db.jpg)
>
>
40272398-4ec4c580-5b61-11e8-85c2-825a5c332636.jpg 40272399-4ee70f28-5b61-11e8-9f0c-76a07ff0c7dd.jpg 40272400-4f0526b6-5b61-11e8-9dee-5843430c226c.jpg 40272401-4f3e03b4-5b61-11e8-827d-e62e9e06c9c0.jpg 40272402-4f69b054-5b61-11e8-80c7-a13f9c6ef874.jpg 40272403-4fc953e2-5b61-11e8-8295-9c9aa1b76a94.jpg 40503445-ed5d77f2-5f42-11e8-97f5-6148da998ecf.jpg 40503446-ed78eff0-5f42-11e8-807d-be79ac09b5db.jpg
 
Changed:
<
<
### Cosmic rays and detector artifacts
>
>

Cosmic rays and detector artifacts

  Some of these artifacts can look very similar to real FMOs. The key is that the edge of these artifacts are "hard" (because they lack the atmospheric/optical effect that real FMOs should have)
Changed:
<
<
![strkid5083081149150001_pid508308114915_scimref](40503447-ed985d36-5f42-11e8-8055-31e8efda293d.jpg) ![strkid5081991749150001_pid508199174915_scimref](40503448-edbb3626-5f42-11e8-8ab5-4c63fa2a223f.jpg) ![strkid5083057853150001_pid508305785315_scimref](40503449-ee01ffd4-5f42-11e8-9e95-5da9fccc6df1.jpg) ![strkid5082671613150001_pid508267161315_scimref](40503450-ee2395d6-5f42-11e8-809b-999104a99d74.jpg)
>
>
40503447-ed985d36-5f42-11e8-8055-31e8efda293d.jpg 40503448-edbb3626-5f42-11e8-8ab5-4c63fa2a223f.jpg 40503449-ee01ffd4-5f42-11e8-9e95-5da9fccc6df1.jpg 40503450-ee2395d6-5f42-11e8-809b-999104a99d74.jpg
 
Changed:
<
<
### Bad subtractions
>
>

Bad subtractions

  ZTF pipeline will subtract stationary objects (mostly background stars). The pipeline may report residuals as possible FMOs when the subtraction is not done perfectly.
Changed:
<
<
![strkid5034793157150002_pid503479315715_scimref](40272367-d63d3a20-5b60-11e8-8ddc-4dec5909fe9e.jpg) ![strkid5032820961150001_pid503282096115_scimref](40272368-d65e7172-5b60-11e8-9f2d-9b78db1dd69b.jpg) ![strkid5034523110150009_pid503452311015_scimref](40272369-d67f665c-5b60-11e8-8957-a8694f0e5c44.jpg) ![strkid5094276721150009_pid509427672115_scimref](40589039-c221d492-619b-11e8-8b09-32ee6d040205.jpg)
>
>
40272367-d63d3a20-5b60-11e8-8ddc-4dec5909fe9e.jpg 40272368-d65e7172-5b60-11e8-9f2d-9b78db1dd69b.jpg 40272369-d67f665c-5b60-11e8-8957-a8694f0e5c44.jpg 40589039-c221d492-619b-11e8-8b09-32ee6d040205.jpg
 
Changed:
<
<
### Blank stamps
>
>

Blank stamps

  Stamps that contain nothing.
Changed:
<
<
![2c25aaff-ab66-4231-81e9-d678bcae4060](40581261-328af518-6108-11e8-831f-35c0bad18cd3.jpeg) ![bf032c34-ddf7-41b6-af9b-d8b14bd71d54](40581262-32a2c94a-6108-11e8-8cd3-296654844db8.jpeg) ![99b8bc6f-e76d-4dd5-ad0b-68d995c619c1](40581263-32ba5d12-6108-11e8-8389-a3037ba4f115.jpeg)
>
>
40581261-328af518-6108-11e8-831f-35c0bad18cd3.jpeg 40581262-32a2c94a-6108-11e8-8cd3-296654844db8.jpeg 40581263-32ba5d12-6108-11e8-8389-a3037ba4f115.jpeg
 

Changed:
<
<
-- EmilyKramer - 06 Aug 2018
>
>
-- EmilyKramer - 10 Aug 2018

Revision 12018-08-06 - EmilyKramer

Line: 1 to 1
Added:
>
>
META TOPICPARENT name="NEOZTFScanning"
How to find Fast Moving Objects (FMOs)

Originally by Quan-Zhi Ye

You will be given a number of "stamps" that contain plausible FMOs identified by the ZTF pipeline. The challenge is to identify what we would consider a real (asteroidal) FMO.

What does a real FMO look like?

A real FMO will look like a star smeared across the image. The edge should be soft due to atmospheric and optic effect on the light, and the width and brightness should be somewhat uniform. As ZTF has relatively short exposure time (30 seconds), a real asteroidal FMO usually does not extend beyond the size of the stamp (which is about 150 by 150 arcsec). Anything longer than that is most likely an artificial object.

40502730-b141d364-5f40-11e8-951d-de10b3f8858d.jpg 2018 KM1, a real asteroidal FMO.

40502728-b0e860e0-5f40-11e8-9075-f2717d3266fa.jpg This is actually a high-orbit satellite or space debris, but its appearance is identical to a real FMO and you should classify it as such. We will not know whether it is an artificial object or a natural asteroid until we calculate its orbit.

40502729-b1248070-5f40-11e8-9ebc-4b5e773acc1b.jpg Also, this one turns out to be an artificial object later, but it should be classify as a real FMO.

41264667-d3a6b378-6da2-11e8-9b8a-d4816b809285.jpg Not all FMOs are as bright as the examples shown above. Actually, most new ones are faint -- like this one (R~18.5).

Common falses

### Long tracks caused by artificial objects (satellites, aircrafts, space debris)

The most common falses are artificial objects. Anything that extends beyond the edge of the stamp or shows non-uniform changes in width or brightness is most likely artificial objects -- don't bother!

Note that ZTF data pipeline is designed to mask out satellite tracks, but sometimes it only mask out part of those tracks. Pay attention to the masks as sometimes partially masked tracks look like legit real FMOs.

40316088-083e1e82-5cd2-11e8-8617-e4b24e035a24.jpg Note that part of this track is masked out, making it looking like a real FMO

40272283-bb2d16fc-5b5f-11e8-960a-adbb0aa76b59.jpg Note that part of this track is masked out, making it looking like a real FMO

40272287-bbb4f432-5b5f-11e8-94ce-cbe93b52d070.jpg This is too long to be a real FMO, note that some portions are masked out by the ZTF pipeline

## Flashes caused by artificial objects

Similar to the category above but objects in this class can be quite confusing -- remember that anything that shows non-uniform changes in width or brightness is most likely artificial objects.

![strkid5033298019150001_pid503329801915_scimref](40272285-bb53b640-5b5f-11e8-94ff-668e2531e87f.jpg) This candidate is short in length, however the brightness is not uniform along the streak, therefore it is most likely a satellite flash

![strkid5033038548150003_pid503303854815_scimref](40272286-bb738344-5b5f-11e8-9db3-8792eca4f466.jpg) This object is apparently flashing

![strkid5082263559150009_pid508226355915_scimref](40502300-655fc2c2-5f3f-11e8-83b5-fdedb1a2100b.jpg) Another object that flashes periodically

![strkid5083605902150005_pid508360590215_scimref](40502301-65819438-5f3f-11e8-884e-13de8e6a9c08.jpg) Flash, note that both ends are fading away

![strkid5083687555150007_pid508368755515_scimref](40502302-659eddc2-5f3f-11e8-9c1f-b2573bf29a74.jpg) Flash, note that both ends are fading away

### Masked bright star and/or its diffraction spikes

These are found next to a bright, and usually masked, star.

![strkid5034440300150003_pid503444030015_scimref](40272423-96eb108a-5b61-11e8-929d-1ad302fdb1d3.jpg) ![strkid5034107027150003_pid503410702715_scimref](40272424-971a67b8-5b61-11e8-9f8e-8fde959eefb7.jpg) ![strkid5034793134150004_pid503479313415_scimref](40272425-973aceea-5b61-11e8-9728-58a2f06bfcf3.jpg)

### Dementors and ghosts

Various optical illusions can generate FMO-like features. Compared to real FMOs, optical illusions are more fuzzy, with variable brightness along the track, and are usually non-linear.

![strkid5033932721150001_pid503393272115_scimref](40272398-4ec4c580-5b61-11e8-85c2-825a5c332636.jpg) ![strkid5033676561150005_pid503367656115_scimref](40272399-4ee70f28-5b61-11e8-9f0c-76a07ff0c7dd.jpg) ![strkid5033676552150005_pid503367655215_scimref](40272400-4f0526b6-5b61-11e8-9dee-5843430c226c.jpg) ![strkid5033810361150002_pid503381036115_scimref](40272401-4f3e03b4-5b61-11e8-827d-e62e9e06c9c0.jpg) ![strkid5033932719150005_pid503393271915_scimref](40272402-4f69b054-5b61-11e8-80c7-a13f9c6ef874.jpg) ![strkid5032262201150001_pid503226220115_scimref](40272403-4fc953e2-5b61-11e8-8295-9c9aa1b76a94.jpg) ![strkid5082246151150001_pid508224615115_scimref](40503445-ed5d77f2-5f42-11e8-97f5-6148da998ecf.jpg) ![strkid5082201203150001_pid508220120315_scimref](40503446-ed78eff0-5f42-11e8-807d-be79ac09b5db.jpg)

### Cosmic rays and detector artifacts

Some of these artifacts can look very similar to real FMOs. The key is that the edge of these artifacts are "hard" (because they lack the atmospheric/optical effect that real FMOs should have)

![strkid5083081149150001_pid508308114915_scimref](40503447-ed985d36-5f42-11e8-8055-31e8efda293d.jpg) ![strkid5081991749150001_pid508199174915_scimref](40503448-edbb3626-5f42-11e8-8ab5-4c63fa2a223f.jpg) ![strkid5083057853150001_pid508305785315_scimref](40503449-ee01ffd4-5f42-11e8-9e95-5da9fccc6df1.jpg) ![strkid5082671613150001_pid508267161315_scimref](40503450-ee2395d6-5f42-11e8-809b-999104a99d74.jpg)

### Bad subtractions

ZTF pipeline will subtract stationary objects (mostly background stars). The pipeline may report residuals as possible FMOs when the subtraction is not done perfectly.

![strkid5034793157150002_pid503479315715_scimref](40272367-d63d3a20-5b60-11e8-8ddc-4dec5909fe9e.jpg) ![strkid5032820961150001_pid503282096115_scimref](40272368-d65e7172-5b60-11e8-9f2d-9b78db1dd69b.jpg) ![strkid5034523110150009_pid503452311015_scimref](40272369-d67f665c-5b60-11e8-8957-a8694f0e5c44.jpg) ![strkid5094276721150009_pid509427672115_scimref](40589039-c221d492-619b-11e8-8b09-32ee6d040205.jpg)

### Blank stamps

Stamps that contain nothing.

![2c25aaff-ab66-4231-81e9-d678bcae4060](40581261-328af518-6108-11e8-831f-35c0bad18cd3.jpeg) ![bf032c34-ddf7-41b6-af9b-d8b14bd71d54](40581262-32a2c94a-6108-11e8-8cd3-296654844db8.jpeg) ![99b8bc6f-e76d-4dd5-ad0b-68d995c619c1](40581263-32ba5d12-6108-11e8-8389-a3037ba4f115.jpeg)

-- EmilyKramer - 06 Aug 2018

 
This site is powered by the TWiki collaboration platform Powered by PerlCopyright © 2008-2025 by the contributing authors. All material on this collaboration platform is the property of the contributing authors.
Ideas, requests, problems regarding TWiki? Send feedback