ElexMiniReview < Keck/NGAO

---++ NGAO Electronics Architecture Mini Design Review, 26 January 2010

*Review Schedule*
   * Material to web site: 15-Jan
   * Response from reviewers due: end of day 22-Jan
   * Design group's response to reviewer questions: 25-Jan (as soon as possible)
   * Review meeting: 8:00am-12:00pm (HST) 26-Jan

   * Videoconference IP: 128.171.99.70 (hualalai)
   * Telecon number: 1-877-280-4645 Guest Room: 540030

Links to review materials
   * Charge to Reviewers
      * [[%ATTACHURL%/CE_Charter.pdf][CE_Charter.pdf]]: Review Committee charter document

   * Requirements
      * [[%ATTACHURL%/electrical_requirements_compliance.xls][electrical_requirements_compliance.xls]]: Requirements Compliance Matrix
         * This spreadsheet has three tabs:
            * The one for Functional Requirements should be the prime focus. <br>
            * The second tab is for new or requested Functional Requirements - things we think are missing. <br>
            * The third tab is System Requirements. These were reviewed, but not in close detail. <br>
         * The compliance column is color coded as follows: 
            * green=compliant
            * red=non-compliant
            * yellow=discussion/update required
            * blue=N/A
         * Comments in the compliance column reference sections of the documents and indicate things that require discussion.<br>
            &nbsp;<br>
         * Please note that given the broad scope of the electronics architecture, it is very difficult to extract all of the relevant requirements from the Contour database.<br>
            The team needs to put more effort into verifying that all of the relevant requirements have been identified, determining compliance and identifying areas of deficiency in both the requirements and compliance.


   * Design Documents
      * %RED% *The version of the documents listed below is frozen as of 15-Jan-10, 17:00 HST.<br>
          These are the versions pertinent to the mini-review on 26-Jan-10. After the review, see NewKAONs
 For the most current version* %ENDCOLOR%
      * [[http://www.oir.caltech.edu/twiki_oir/bin/viewfile/Keck/NGAO/NewKAONs?rev=2;filename=KAON668_NGAO_DeviceArchitecture.doc][KAON 668: Device Architecture]] (v2.0) [[%ATTACHURL%/KAON668_NGAO_DeviceArchitecture_v2.0.pdf][.pdf]]
         * This document describes the devices that need to be controlled. This document is believed to be complete and accurate.
      * [[http://www.oir.caltech.edu/twiki_oir/bin/viewfile/Keck/NGAO/NewKAONs?rev=1;filename=KAON701_NGAOPrelimElectronicsDesign.doc][KAON 701: Preliminary Electronics Design]] (draft v0.1)[[%ATTACHURL%/KAON701_NGAOPrelimElectronicsDesign.pdf][.pdf]]
         * This will be the PD document for the NGAO electronics. <br>
            Each subsystem is broken down and discussed in as much detail as possible.<br>
            As this effort relies heavily on the subsystem designs, this document remains a work in progress. 
         * The following areas are considered to be >75% complete:
            * AO Hatch
            * Wide-field relay
            * LGS WFS
            * Laser Switchyard
            * Laser Beam Transport
            * Laser BGS
         * Areas of significant deficiency include:
            * Calibration/Simulation subsystem
            * LOWFS
            * NGS WFS
            * IR ADC
            * Laser Units
            * Laser Service Enclosure
            * Control computers
            * RTC
            * Time Infrastructure
            * Science Instruments
            * Cost analysis
            * Risk/mitigation
            * Plans/Schedule for DD phase
         * Areas not addressed specifically are considered 50-75% complete.
      * [[%ATTACHURL%/KAON682_NGAO_Master_Device_List_1_1.xls][KAON 682: Master Device List Excel Spreadsheet]]: Master Device List - version 1.1 pertinent to mini-review
         * This document captures all of the known devices requiring control. <br>
            There are two tabs, one for motion devices (not part of this review) and one for non-motion devices.<br>
            Non-motion devices highlighted in yellow are part of this review. 

   * Supplemental Materials
      * [[%NGAO_KAON%KAON511_NGAO_SDM_v2.1.doc][KAON 511: System Design Manual v2.1 (doc)]] 
      * [[%NGAO_KAON%KAON642_NGAO_Design_Changes.doc][KAON 642: Design Changes in Support of Build-to-Cost]]
      * [[http://www.oir.caltech.edu/twiki_oir/pub/Keck/NGAO/SystemsEngAnalysis/KAON680.doc][KAON 680: Vibration Mitigation]]

   * Response To Reviewer Comments
      * Compliance Matrix w/ Reviewer Comments & Response: [[%ATTACHURL%/electrical_requirements_compliance_response.xls][.xls]]
      * Responses in the documents below are %RED%listed in RED.%ENDCOLOR%
      * Response to Peter's Comments (v1.2) [[%ATTACHURL%/Response_Wizinowich.doc][.doc]]
      * Response to Rich's Comments (v1.1) [[%ATTACHURL%/Response_Dekany.doc][.doc]]
      * Response to Kent's Comments (v1.1) [[%ATTACHURL%/Response_Wallace.doc][.doc]]
      * Response to Thomas Stalcup's Comments (v1.0) [[%ATTACHURL%/Response_Stalcup.doc][.doc]]
      * Response to Tomas Krasuski's Comments (v1.0) [[%ATTACHURL%/Response_Krasuski.doc][.doc]]
      * Response to Viswa's Comments (v1.0) [[%ATTACHURL%/Response_Velur.doc][.doc]]

   * *Review Presentation [[%ATTACHURL%/electornicsMiniReview.ppt][.ppt]], [[%ATTACHURL%/electornicsMiniReview.pdf][.pdf]]*

   * *Reviewers' final report: [[%NGAO_KAON%KAON_711_Control_Electronics_Commitee_Report.doc][KAON_711_Control_Electronics_Commitee_Report.doc]]*

Reviewer panel:
   * Thomas Stalcup (chair)
   * Tomas Krasuski
   * Rich Dekany

-- Main.EdWetherell - 11 Jan 2010
Attachments
Topic attachments
I	Attachment	History	Action	Size	Date	Who	Comment
doc	Control_Electronics_Commitee_Report_(2).doc	r1	manage	36.5 K	2010-02-19 - 17:52	UnknownUser	Review Committee final report
xls	KAON682_NGAO_Master_Device_List_1_1.xls	r1	manage	94.5 K	2010-04-26 - 19:44	UnknownUser	Master Device List - version pertinent to mini-review
This topic: Keck/NGAO > WebHome > ControlsSystems > ControlsSystemsHWArch > ElexMiniReview
Topic revision: r25 - 2010-04-26 - EdWetherell