Difference: MotionMiniReview (1 vs. 16)

Revision 162010-04-26 - EdWetherell

Line: 1 to 1
 
META TOPICPARENT name="ControlsSystemsHWArch"

NGAO Motion Control Architecture Mini Design Review, 11 March 2010

Line: 25 to 25
 
      • This will be the PD document for the NGAO Motion Controls.
        Each subsystem is broken down and discussed in as much detail as possible.
        As this effort relies heavily on the subsystem designs, this document remains a work in progress.
Changed:
<
<
>
>
 
      • This document captures all of the known devices controlled by the AO or LGS control system.
        RTC devices are not listed.
        There are two tabs, one for motion devices and one for non-motion devices (not part of this review).
Line: 69 to 69
 
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="MC_miniReview_presentation.ppt" attr="" comment="mini-review presentation (final)" date="1268327874" name="MC_miniReview_presentation.ppt" path="MC_miniReview_presentation_v2.ppt" size="4979712" stream="MC_miniReview_presentation_v2.ppt" user="Main.EdWetherell" version="2"
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="MC_miniReview_presentation.pdf" attr="" comment="mini-review presentation (final)" date="1268327898" name="MC_miniReview_presentation.pdf" path="MC_miniReview_presentation.pdf" size="525963" stream="MC_miniReview_presentation.pdf" user="Main.EdWetherell" version="1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="Notes_on_Motion_Control_Review_March112010_(2).doc" attr="" comment="Motion Control Electronics Mini-Review Review Committee Report" date="1270260634" name="Notes_on_Motion_Control_Review_March112010_(2).doc" path="Notes on Motion Control Review_March112010 (2).doc" size="55296" stream="Notes on Motion Control Review_March112010 (2).doc" user="Main.KevinTsubota" version="1"
Added:
>
>
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="KAON682_NGAO_Master_Device_List_1_2.xls" attr="" comment="Master Device List - version 1.2 pertinent to mini-review" date="1272311217" name="KAON682_NGAO_Master_Device_List_1_2.xls" path="KAON682_NGAO_Master_Device_List_1_2.xls" size="103424" stream="KAON682_NGAO_Master_Device_List_1_2.xls" user="Main.EdWetherell" version="1"

Revision 152010-04-03 - KevinTsubota

Line: 1 to 1
 
META TOPICPARENT name="ControlsSystemsHWArch"

NGAO Motion Control Architecture Mini Design Review, 11 March 2010

Line: 49 to 49
 
Changed:
<
<
  • Reviewers' final report
>
>
  • Reviewers' final report .doc
  Reviewer panel:
  • Don Gavel (chair)
Line: 73 to 68
 
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="KAON682_pw.pdf" attr="" comment="Peter's comments on KAON682 w/ response" date="1268325040" name="KAON682_pw.pdf" path="KAON682_pw.pdf" size="24587" stream="KAON682_pw.pdf" user="Main.EdWetherell" version="1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="MC_miniReview_presentation.ppt" attr="" comment="mini-review presentation (final)" date="1268327874" name="MC_miniReview_presentation.ppt" path="MC_miniReview_presentation_v2.ppt" size="4979712" stream="MC_miniReview_presentation_v2.ppt" user="Main.EdWetherell" version="2"
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="MC_miniReview_presentation.pdf" attr="" comment="mini-review presentation (final)" date="1268327898" name="MC_miniReview_presentation.pdf" path="MC_miniReview_presentation.pdf" size="525963" stream="MC_miniReview_presentation.pdf" user="Main.EdWetherell" version="1"
Added:
>
>
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="Notes_on_Motion_Control_Review_March112010_(2).doc" attr="" comment="Motion Control Electronics Mini-Review Review Committee Report" date="1270260634" name="Notes_on_Motion_Control_Review_March112010_(2).doc" path="Notes on Motion Control Review_March112010 (2).doc" size="55296" stream="Notes on Motion Control Review_March112010 (2).doc" user="Main.KevinTsubota" version="1"

Revision 142010-03-11 - EdWetherell

Line: 1 to 1
 
META TOPICPARENT name="ControlsSystemsHWArch"

NGAO Motion Control Architecture Mini Design Review, 11 March 2010

Line: 37 to 37
 
Changed:
<
<
  • Reviewer Comments
>
>
  • Reviewer Comments + Respnose
 
Added:
>
>
      • Minor comments, comments covered in review
 
Changed:
<
<
>
>
 
Deleted:
<
<
  • Review Presentation .ppt
 
Added:
>
>
 
  • Reviewers' final report
Line: 63 to 68
 
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.doc" attr="" comment="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign with Alex's comments" date="1268095413" name="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.doc" path="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.doc" size="5371392" stream="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.doc" user="Main.AlexDelacroix" version="1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.pdf" attr="" comment="* KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.doc: KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign with Alex's comments" date="1268095722" name="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.pdf" path="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.pdf" size="618122" stream="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.pdf" user="Main.AlexDelacroix" version="1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="Questions_Comments_JC.doc" attr="" comment="Feedback from Jason" date="1268181282" name="Questions_Comments_JC.doc" path="Questions Comments JC.doc" size="54272" stream="Questions Comments JC.doc" user="Main.EdWetherell" version="1"
Deleted:
<
<
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="MC_miniReview_presentation_v1.ppt" attr="" comment="mini-review presentation" date="1268288743" name="MC_miniReview_presentation_v1.ppt" path="MC_miniReview_presentation_v1.ppt" size="5220352" stream="MC_miniReview_presentation_v1.ppt" user="Main.EdWetherell" version="1"
 
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="CommentsOnMotionControlReview_DG.doc" attr="" comment="comments from Don" date="1268288776" name="CommentsOnMotionControlReview_DG.doc" path="CommentsOnMotionControlReview_DG.doc" size="57856" stream="CommentsOnMotionControlReview_DG.doc" user="Main.EdWetherell" version="1"
Added:
>
>
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign_pw.doc" attr="" comment="Peter's comments on KAON715" date="1268324749" name="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign_pw.doc" path="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign_pw.doc" size="5586944" stream="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign_pw.doc" user="Main.EdWetherell" version="1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="KAON682_pw.pdf" attr="" comment="Peter's comments on KAON682 w/ response" date="1268325040" name="KAON682_pw.pdf" path="KAON682_pw.pdf" size="24587" stream="KAON682_pw.pdf" user="Main.EdWetherell" version="1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="MC_miniReview_presentation.ppt" attr="" comment="mini-review presentation (final)" date="1268327874" name="MC_miniReview_presentation.ppt" path="MC_miniReview_presentation_v2.ppt" size="4979712" stream="MC_miniReview_presentation_v2.ppt" user="Main.EdWetherell" version="2"
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="MC_miniReview_presentation.pdf" attr="" comment="mini-review presentation (final)" date="1268327898" name="MC_miniReview_presentation.pdf" path="MC_miniReview_presentation.pdf" size="525963" stream="MC_miniReview_presentation.pdf" user="Main.EdWetherell" version="1"

Revision 132010-03-11 - EdWetherell

Line: 1 to 1
 
META TOPICPARENT name="ControlsSystemsHWArch"

NGAO Motion Control Architecture Mini Design Review, 11 March 2010

Line: 41 to 41
 
Changed:
<
<
>
>
 
  • Response To Reviewer Comments
Changed:
<
<
  • Review Presentation
<--
.ppt, .pdf*
-->
>
>
  • Review Presentation .ppt
 
  • Reviewers' final report
Line: 63 to 63
 
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.doc" attr="" comment="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign with Alex's comments" date="1268095413" name="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.doc" path="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.doc" size="5371392" stream="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.doc" user="Main.AlexDelacroix" version="1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.pdf" attr="" comment="* KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.doc: KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign with Alex's comments" date="1268095722" name="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.pdf" path="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.pdf" size="618122" stream="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.pdf" user="Main.AlexDelacroix" version="1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="Questions_Comments_JC.doc" attr="" comment="Feedback from Jason" date="1268181282" name="Questions_Comments_JC.doc" path="Questions Comments JC.doc" size="54272" stream="Questions Comments JC.doc" user="Main.EdWetherell" version="1"
Added:
>
>
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="MC_miniReview_presentation_v1.ppt" attr="" comment="mini-review presentation" date="1268288743" name="MC_miniReview_presentation_v1.ppt" path="MC_miniReview_presentation_v1.ppt" size="5220352" stream="MC_miniReview_presentation_v1.ppt" user="Main.EdWetherell" version="1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="CommentsOnMotionControlReview_DG.doc" attr="" comment="comments from Don" date="1268288776" name="CommentsOnMotionControlReview_DG.doc" path="CommentsOnMotionControlReview_DG.doc" size="57856" stream="CommentsOnMotionControlReview_DG.doc" user="Main.EdWetherell" version="1"

Revision 122010-03-10 - EdWetherell

Line: 1 to 1
 
META TOPICPARENT name="ControlsSystemsHWArch"

NGAO Motion Control Architecture Mini Design Review, 11 March 2010

Line: 40 to 40
 
Added:
>
>
 
  • Response To Reviewer Comments
Line: 66 to 62
 
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="Limit_switch_with_distance_and_direction.pdf" attr="" comment="Limit Switch with direction and distance" date="1268083216" name="Limit_switch_with_distance_and_direction.pdf" path="Limit switch with distance and direction.pdf" size="265975" stream="Limit switch with distance and direction.pdf" user="Main.AlexDelacroix" version="1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.doc" attr="" comment="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign with Alex's comments" date="1268095413" name="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.doc" path="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.doc" size="5371392" stream="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.doc" user="Main.AlexDelacroix" version="1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.pdf" attr="" comment="* KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.doc: KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign with Alex's comments" date="1268095722" name="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.pdf" path="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.pdf" size="618122" stream="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.pdf" user="Main.AlexDelacroix" version="1"
Added:
>
>
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="Questions_Comments_JC.doc" attr="" comment="Feedback from Jason" date="1268181282" name="Questions_Comments_JC.doc" path="Questions Comments JC.doc" size="54272" stream="Questions Comments JC.doc" user="Main.EdWetherell" version="1"

Revision 112010-03-09 - EdWetherell

Line: 1 to 1
 
META TOPICPARENT name="ControlsSystemsHWArch"

NGAO Motion Control Architecture Mini Design Review, 11 March 2010

Revision 102010-03-09 - AlexDelacroix

Line: 1 to 1
 
META TOPICPARENT name="ControlsSystemsHWArch"

NGAO Motion Control Architecture Mini Design Review, 11 March 2010

Line: 39 to 39
 
  • Reviewer Comments
Added:
>
>
 

  • Response To Reviewer Comments
Line: 60 to 61
 
Added:
>
>
 
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="MC_miniReview_charter_v1.pdf" attr="" comment="Motion Control Mini-Review Charter" date="1267496289" name="MC_miniReview_charter_v1.pdf" path="MC_miniReview_charter_v1.pdf" size="38797" stream="MC_miniReview_charter_v1.pdf" user="Main.KevinTsubota" version="2"
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="Limit_switch_with_distance_and_direction.pdf" attr="" comment="Limit Switch with direction and distance" date="1268083216" name="Limit_switch_with_distance_and_direction.pdf" path="Limit switch with distance and direction.pdf" size="265975" stream="Limit switch with distance and direction.pdf" user="Main.AlexDelacroix" version="1"
Added:
>
>
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.doc" attr="" comment="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign with Alex's comments" date="1268095413" name="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.doc" path="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.doc" size="5371392" stream="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.doc" user="Main.AlexDelacroix" version="1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.pdf" attr="" comment="* KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.doc: KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign with Alex's comments" date="1268095722" name="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.pdf" path="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.pdf" size="618122" stream="KAON715_NGAOPrelimMotionDesign-1-Alex.pdf" user="Main.AlexDelacroix" version="1"

Revision 92010-03-08 - AlexDelacroix

Line: 1 to 1
 
META TOPICPARENT name="ControlsSystemsHWArch"

NGAO Motion Control Architecture Mini Design Review, 11 March 2010

Line: 37 to 37
 
Changed:
<
<
  • Response To Reviewer Comments
>
>
  • Reviewer Comments

 
Added:
>
>
  • Response To Reviewer Comments
 
  • Review Presentation

Revision 82010-03-05 - KevinTsubota

Line: 1 to 1
 
META TOPICPARENT name="ControlsSystemsHWArch"

NGAO Motion Control Architecture Mini Design Review, 11 March 2010

Line: 8 to 8
 
  • Design group's response to reviewer questions: as soon as possible
  • Review meeting: 8:00am-12:00pm (HST) 11-Mar
Changed:
<
<
  • Videoconference IP: 128.171.99.69 (Kamuela)
>
>
  • Videoconference IP: 128.171.99.70 (Hualalai)
 
  • Telecon number: 1-877-280-4645 Guest Room: 540030

Links to review materials

Revision 72010-03-05 - EdWetherell

Line: 1 to 1
 
META TOPICPARENT name="ControlsSystemsHWArch"

NGAO Motion Control Architecture Mini Design Review, 11 March 2010

Line: 16 to 16
 

  • Requirements
Changed:
<
<
>
>
    • See section 7 of KAON 715 (below)
 
  • Design Documents
    • *The version of the documents listed below is frozen as of 4-Mar-10, 17:00 HST.
Changed:
<
<
These are the versions pertinent to the mini-review on 4-Mar-10. After the review, see NewKAONs
>
>
These are the versions pertinent to the mini-review on 11-Mar-10. After the review, see NewKAONs
  For the most current version*
Changed:
<
<
>
>
    • KAON 715: Preliminary Motion Control Design (v1.0)
      • This will be the PD document for the NGAO Motion Controls.
        Each subsystem is broken down and discussed in as much detail as possible.
        As this effort relies heavily on the subsystem designs, this document remains a work in progress.
 
Changed:
<
<
      • This document captures all of the known devices requiring control.
>
>
      • This document captures all of the known devices controlled by the AO or LGS control system.
        RTC devices are not listed.
  There are two tabs, one for motion devices and one for non-motion devices (not part of this review).
Line: 35 to 39
 
  • Response To Reviewer Comments
Changed:
<
<
>
>
  • Review Presentation
<--
.ppt, .pdf*
-->
 
  • Reviewers' final report

Revision 62010-03-05 - EdWetherell

Line: 1 to 1
 
META TOPICPARENT name="ControlsSystemsHWArch"

NGAO Motion Control Architecture Mini Design Review, 11 March 2010

Line: 8 to 8
 
  • Design group's response to reviewer questions: as soon as possible
  • Review meeting: 8:00am-12:00pm (HST) 11-Mar
Changed:
<
<
  • Videoconference IP: 128.171.99.?? (Kamuela)
>
>
  • Videoconference IP: 128.171.99.69 (Kamuela)
 
  • Telecon number: 1-877-280-4645 Guest Room: 540030

Links to review materials

Line: 40 to 40
 
  • Reviewers' final report

Reviewer panel:

Changed:
<
<
>
>
  • Don Gavel (chair)
  • Alex Delacroix
  • Tomas Krasuski
  -- EdWetherell - 18 Feb 2010

Revision 52010-03-05 - KevinTsubota

Line: 1 to 1
 
META TOPICPARENT name="ControlsSystemsHWArch"

NGAO Motion Control Architecture Mini Design Review, 11 March 2010

Line: 8 to 8
 
  • Design group's response to reviewer questions: as soon as possible
  • Review meeting: 8:00am-12:00pm (HST) 11-Mar
Changed:
<
<
  • Videoconference IP: 128.171.99.70 (hualalai)
>
>
  • Videoconference IP: 128.171.99.?? (Kamuela)
 
  • Telecon number: 1-877-280-4645 Guest Room: 540030

Links to review materials

Revision 42010-03-05 - EdWetherell

Line: 1 to 1
 
META TOPICPARENT name="ControlsSystemsHWArch"

NGAO Motion Control Architecture Mini Design Review, 11 March 2010

Line: 22 to 22
  These are the versions pertinent to the mini-review on 4-Mar-10. After the review, see NewKAONs For the most current version*
Changed:
<
<
>
>
 
      • This document captures all of the known devices requiring control.
        There are two tabs, one for motion devices and one for non-motion devices (not part of this review).
    • KAON 668: Motioin Control Architecture Study (v1.5)

Revision 32010-03-02 - KevinTsubota

Line: 1 to 1
 
META TOPICPARENT name="ControlsSystemsHWArch"

NGAO Motion Control Architecture Mini Design Review, 11 March 2010

Line: 13 to 13
  Links to review materials
  • Charge to Reviewers
Changed:
<
<
>
>
 
Line: 43 to 43
 

-- EdWetherell - 18 Feb 2010

Added:
>
>

META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="MC_miniReview_charter_v1.pdf" attr="" comment="Motion Control Mini-Review Charter" date="1267496289" name="MC_miniReview_charter_v1.pdf" path="MC_miniReview_charter_v1.pdf" size="38797" stream="MC_miniReview_charter_v1.pdf" user="Main.KevinTsubota" version="2"

Revision 22010-02-26 - EdWetherell

Line: 1 to 1
 
META TOPICPARENT name="ControlsSystemsHWArch"

NGAO Motion Control Architecture Mini Design Review, 11 March 2010

Line: 21 to 21
 
    • The version of the documents listed below is frozen as of 4-Mar-10, 17:00 HST.
      These are the versions pertinent to the mini-review on 4-Mar-10. After the review, see NewKAONs For the most current version
Changed:
<
<
>
>
 
Added:
>
>
    • KAON 668: Motioin Control Architecture Study (v1.5)
      • This document presents an initial study into the motion control requirements and possible architectures.
      • This document has not been revised to reflect the current quantity and type of devices expected in the NGAO system.
 

Revision 12010-02-18 - EdWetherell

Line: 1 to 1
Added:
>
>
META TOPICPARENT name="ControlsSystemsHWArch"

NGAO Motion Control Architecture Mini Design Review, 11 March 2010

Review Schedule

  • Material to web site: 4-Mar
  • Response from reviewers due: end of day 9-Mar
  • Design group's response to reviewer questions: as soon as possible
  • Review meeting: 8:00am-12:00pm (HST) 11-Mar

  • Videoconference IP: 128.171.99.70 (hualalai)
  • Telecon number: 1-877-280-4645 Guest Room: 540030

Links to review materials

  • Charge to Reviewers

  • Requirements
  • Design Documents
    • The version of the documents listed below is frozen as of 4-Mar-10, 17:00 HST.
      These are the versions pertinent to the mini-review on 4-Mar-10. After the review, see NewKAONs For the most current version
    • KAON 668: Motioin Control Architecture Study (v1.3)
      • This document presents an initial study into the motion control requirements and possible architectures.
    • KAON 682: Master Device List Excel Spreadsheet (v1.1)
      • This document captures all of the known devices requiring control.
        There are two tabs, one for motion devices and one for non-motion devices (not part of this review).

  • Response To Reviewer Comments

  • Reviewers' final report

Reviewer panel:

-- EdWetherell - 18 Feb 2010

 
This site is powered by the TWiki collaboration platform Powered by PerlCopyright © 2008-2020 by the contributing authors. All material on this collaboration platform is the property of the contributing authors.
Ideas, requests, problems regarding TWiki? Send feedback